The Nutty Professor (1996)

IMDb plot summary: Grossly overweight yet good-hearted professor Sherman Klump takes a special chemical that turns him into the slim but obnoxious Buddy Love.

Directed by Tom Shadyac. Stars Eddie Murphy, Jada Pinkett Smith, and James Coburn.

The Nutty Professor is a 1996 comedy starring Eddie Murphy as Professor Sherman Klump, a teacher and scientist who is studying methods of weight loss in mice. He himself is a very large person and is frequently the butt of the joke of everyone around him because of it. He eventually becomes desperate and tries his experimental treatment on himself, transforms into his thin, testosterone-filled alter ego, and decides he doesn't want to go back. The final message of this film is clearly intended to be something in a body positive vein -- he learns to appreciate himself and still gets the girl -- but it's all undercut by the fact that every single joke makes his weight a punchline. Even when it's done in a way that we're supposed to feel sympathy for the character, it's still punching down at him. I also don't find much fun in the scenes where Eddie Murphy is playing all the members of the Klump family. None of them are particularly interesting to me, and most of the jokes absolutely do not land. They're just sitting around being gross, which I understand is a very deliberate choice, but it made me anxious for those scenes to end. This is definitely the effect of trying to do a love-yourself-the-size-you-are movie in the 90s, where the cultural fatphobia is so prominent it takes over the story, even if you're kind of trying to speak against it. It ultimately doesn't work, either comedically or narratively.

How it entered my Flickchart:

🎥 The Nutty Professor (1996)

📊 Ranked #3645/4186 on my Flickchart

🎯 Flickscore™: 13

lost to The Sasquatch Gang (held at #2099)

lost to Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban (held at #3147)

beat Star Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones (#3666 → #3667)

lost to Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen (held at #3408)

lost to Freaky Friday (held at #3537)

lost to You Will Meet a Tall Dark Stranger (held at #3601)

lost to Intolerance: Love's Struggle Throughout the Ages (held at #3633)

beat Animal House (#3649 → #3650)

lost to Sky Captain and the World of Tomorrow (held at #3641)

beat Gomorrah (#3645 → #3646)

lost to Darkest Hour (held at #3643)

lost to You Were Never Really Here (held at #3644)